Every election cycle, here it comes. Somebody starts spouting off about voters defecting.

I find myself asking the same question. Who owned that vote in the first place?

I had this problem with “Reagan Democrats.” A fellow who’d voted Democratic for years went into the booth and pulled the lever for Ronald Reagan. Apparently he’d done the political equivalent of showing up on the wrong side of the stadium wearing his old jersey.

Presto! A whole new species of voter for the parties and the press to slice, dice and psychoanalyze.

I’d have liked to ask him what he thought Reagan was going to do for him. I’d also have liked to ask the Democrats what they’d done lately that entitled them to expect his vote.

I’ve been writing since 2000 about what I call “back-pocket elections.” I suspect most elections qualify. Did the people I voted for last time save me money? Am I earning a better living? Looking at the choices on the ballot this time, who makes the most convincing case that I’ll have a little more in my back pocket four years from now?

Say I got a raise. In the meantime the rent went up twice, and when the truck needed four tires I found I could only afford two. Now you’re on television telling me how well the economy’s doing. This, this is helpful?

Here’s one for the folks keeping score. How would you tell the difference between a hardened partisan and somebody who’s asked himself those questions six elections running and come up with the same answer? From the studio, the two look identical. On the seventh election he votes the other way, and suddenly we need a panel to explain what happened to him.

What if he’s been a swing voter all his life? What if a good many of us are?

I wonder about this because of the particular bill of goods we bought along with the Great Orange Presidency. Looking at us from abroad, you could reasonably have concluded that America had gone crazy. Hell, plenty of us reached much the same conclusion from right here at home. Where had our sense gone? Our empathy? Had people we’d known all our lives suddenly developed a taste for cruelty and a hankering to live under a strongman?

Consider the rally coverage. With one microphone-equipped fist, the television folks interviewed the fellow at the Trump rally who said the damnedest thing. There he was again over dinner. You’d think people who believed what he believed were as common as houseflies. Meanwhile, with their other microphone-equipped fist, those same folks were calling our attention to all the empty seats.

Um, wait a minute. You noticed how few people showed up. How did the fellow who did show up get to speak for everybody who stayed home?

I’d have liked to hear from the fellow who voted for Trump and went home. What did he think he was buying with that vote? What was he earning? How much of his daughter’s rent was he helping with? Did he believe Trump could do something about either? Of course, first you’d have to find him. He’s got no particular reason to be standing in front of your camera on a Tuesday night. In my experience, every so often – and only in recent months – you’d hear one pipe up in a video of a council meeting.

There’s an uncomfortable part to this. Suppose my neighbor voted to save himself fifty bucks a month and the consequences landed on somebody else’s doorstep. That somebody has every right to be angry with him. “You were willing to let this happen to me” is one hell of an accusation in its own right. “You wanted this to happen to me” is a different one. Which of those can we honestly say we know? Some true believers, I suspect, would gladly own the second accusation. I’ve also known people who could tell you to the penny what a policy might save them and had scarcely considered what it might cost somebody else.

Maybe I’m naïve. I think the good and decent people we worried had vanished were here all along. In the weeks before the 2024 presidential election, NBC News found that 29 percent of registered voters called themselves MAGA supporters. You’d scarcely have guessed that from the coverage afterward. A mandate! A crushing defeat! A change in the American character! That last one in particular … how on earth did we read that much into a ballot?

Which brings us to this election. The Democrats have a genuine mandate this go-round. They asked voters for the power to do certain things, and voters gave it to them. Fair enough. Now let’s apply the same standard to our own celebration. I’d go easy on saying those voters ‘came back’ to the Democrats. Who says they ever belonged to the party in the first place? A voter could have stood in precisely the same place both times, looking at his paycheck and wondering what he could afford, and voted Republican the first time and Democratic the second. The Democrats have earned themselves a turn.

Democrats have also got something they’re liable to lose the minute they pack for Washington. During the campaign, people could get at them. A candidate might come to your town, ask what was on your mind, and have to stand there while you told her. I’d like to see that arrangement survive the election. This has been a serious oversight, a distinct weakness after past contests.

We know the Republican routine. Take a little vacay, show up in the Beltway, march in lockstep, ignore the howls of your constituents. Democrats have always been more like herding cats. Fine by me, provided the cats can find their way home. I’m hoping Bernie Sanders, AOC, Abdul El-Sayed and especially Zohran Mamdani can persuade more Democrats to keep doing in office what they did to get elected. Come back to the same room frequently. Take questions from the people who voted against you, too. And – most importantly – if you had to compromise on something you promised, have the courtesy to explain the bargain to the people whose votes you asked for. They understood a thing or two about compromise before you got to Washington.

Which brings me, perhaps predictably after blogging since 1999, to another plea for independent blogs. I’d like to see more people writing about their own towns, in voices you could recognize even with the byline covered up. A party has good reason to tell you its town hall went splendidly. A television crew can pack up and leave before the fellow in the third row gets his question answered. Somebody who lives there can write down what he asked, what answer he got, and what happened six months later. Give me a few thousand of those, beholden to neither party nor corporation. This is what RSS is (was) for. This is also what I loved about blogs and blogging. America is a huge country; getting real information about how other folks live, work, play. (And not thrice-damned influencers …)

And if the fellow who could only afford two tires cares to start one himself, so much the better. I’d like to know how he’s getting on. I have, after all, spent a fair bit of this post guessing. He might have an entirely different account of why he voted the way he did.

I’d give him the last word.