Elon Musk and assorted right-wing personalities keep telling us they’re “saving Western Civilization.” White Christian nationalists seem particularly enthusiastic. I keep seeing the phrase. Almost nobody seems to ask what they mean by it.

What in the hell do they think Western Civilization actually is?

Freedom of inquiry? Religious liberty? The right to question authority? The idea that your ancestry doesn’t entitle you to rule your neighbors?

Or just the castles?

And when did democratic socialism become foreign to a civilization that helped produce it?

When the proposed rescue involves obedience to wealthy men, draconian religious conformity and deciding who deserves rights and who ‘doesn’t belong,’ I begin to suspect someone has confused civilization with feudal barbarism.

Western civilization’s achievements include hard-won ways to challenge power. To tell the king he’s an inbred bastard. To ask the priest for evidence. To remind the billionaire that purchasing the microphone does not make him God.

Those are worth saving.

A hereditary pecking order with better telecommunications? We’ve already tried most of that.

Apparently the problem with the Dark Ages was insufficient Wi-Fi.