The Senate has passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. It now falls to you to decide what happens next.

I write as a New Mexican who has spent decades working with people and organizations concerned with the environmental and cultural consequences of industrial development.

I also write as someone who has repeatedly voted for Senator Martin Heinrich, one of this legislation’s principal authors. His involvement has left me deeply disappointed.

I understand the urgency surrounding data centers. Their enormous appetite for electricity threatens to increase costs for ordinary Americans. I understand the need to modernize our electrical grid, expand transmission capacity, and accommodate renewable energy.

But I don’t understand why accomplishing those things requires weakening environmental safeguards, Tribal consultation, historic preservation, and judicial oversight.

Under the Senate-passed legislation, courts could find that an agency violated environmental review requirements yet be prevented from stopping the underlying project from proceeding while those violations are corrected. What good is judicial oversight if the remedy arrives after the damage is done?

This bill has become a Frankenstein monster. What began as a seemingly reasonable effort to address energy affordability has accumulated provisions reaching into some of our most consequential environmental laws. It resembles an old-fashioned legislative bargain, except that instead of trading spending earmarks, the participants are trading away pieces of regulatory protection.

And New Mexico, of all places, knows better. Let us consider a couple of examples, out of many.

We’ve already paid for progress.

In 2000, I worked with the National Park Service on a night-sky brightness project at Chaco Culture National Historical Park. I helped with both the photography and the technical measurements.

The darkness was considered a natural resource. Think about that for a moment. The extraordinary night sky above Chaco was part of what made the place significant, including its relationship to the astronomical knowledge and traditions of the Ancestral Puebloans.

This was before the surrounding petroleum development reached its present extent.

Some archaeological road traces have been damaged so thoroughly by petroleum-industry vehicle traffic that even LiDAR cannot recover what has been lost.

You cannot digitally reconstruct evidence when it has been obliterated. Nor can you restore the darkness of a night sky simply by protecting the land immediately beneath it.

Chaco isn’t just a collection of magnificent buildings behind a National Park Service sign. It’s an interconnected cultural landscape, much of it outside the park’s boundaries.

And its significance doesn’t end where an industrial lease begins.

This isn’t an abstract concern. The National Congress of American Indians has specifically identified Greater Chaco, Mount Taylor, and the Caja del Rio as landscapes potentially affected by these changes. These are New Mexico places, and their significance extends well beyond the boundaries of individual protected properties.

Ask the Navajo what progress costs.

Years ago, I managed the website and provided technical support for the New Mexico Environmental Law Center, which worked with Navajo communities confronting environmental damage. The Navajo experience with uranium mining ought to be required study for anyone proposing to accelerate industrial development. Hundreds of abandoned uranium mines. Contaminated land and water. Generations of health consequences. Decades of remediation, much of it still unfinished.

The uranium was extracted for purposes the federal government considered essential to national security.

The benefits were national. The damage was local.

And the consequences lasted long after the economic and strategic imperatives that justified the mining had passed.

Now Americans are becoming understandably alarmed about data centers. Electricity bills. Noise. Water consumption. Pollution. Industrial development encroaching on their communities. You don’t have to be Native to appreciate the irony of communities that have historically benefited from the expansion of industrial development getting a first-hand look at one small aspect of indigenous experience.

Surprise! Suddenly, these concerns command enormous political attention.

Good. They should.

But Indigenous communities have been describing the consequences of industrial development for generations. Their experience isn’t merely a historical grievance. It is expertise, purchased at an appalling price.

Why aren’t we learning from it?

Or ask the people of Pecos Canyon.

The old Terrero Mine and its associated waste left a legacy that culminated in the catastrophic 1991 fish kill in the Pecos River. More than 90,000 fish died, long after the mine was abandoned.

Millions of dollars and years of remediation followed.

The river has recovered substantially, thanks to cleanup efforts and the continuing work of people who care about the watershed. But mine waste remains contained in engineered disposal areas, and monitoring remains important. New Mexico’s fish-consumption advisories also remind us that a river’s apparent health doesn’t tell us everything about the contaminants within it.

And now there is renewed interest in mining the Upper Pecos region, including areas near Holy Ghost Canyon.

The old industry departed. The public inherited the consequences. And another industry proposal arrives with promises of economic opportunity.

Senator Heinrich, in particular, knows this history. He has advocated protecting the Pecos watershed from renewed mining. Which makes me wonder how he reconciles that advocacy with legislation that would change the environmental reviews and legal remedies available to communities confronting industrial development.

The bill would also narrow the authority of states and Tribes to impose water-quality protections under the Clean Water Act. In a state where water is already precious, and where we have firsthand experience with the consequences of mining contamination, that deserves considerably more scrutiny.

Who benefits, exactly?

Data-center expansion is being financed by some of the wealthiest corporations and investment institutions on the planet. American technology companies, multinational corporations, private equity, sovereign wealth funds.

Some of these developments will create jobs, generate tax revenue, and provide useful infrastructure. I don’t dispute that.

But a corporation’s profitability is not synonymous with the prosperity of American citizens.

Who pays for the transmission infrastructure? Who provides the water? Who absorbs the environmental risks? How many permanent local jobs remain when construction is finished? Who profits when the facilities are sold, refinanced, or leased?

And if the development causes damage twenty or thirty years from now, who pays to repair it?

New Mexico has considerable experience answering that last question. The public does.

Sometimes for generations.

This sounds disturbingly familiar.

There’s an old American habit of declaring development inevitable, then treating everyone and everything in its path as an obstacle to progress.

We once gave that philosophy a grand name: Manifest Destiny.

I’m not suggesting that BAAJA is literally nineteenth-century territorial expansion. But I recognize something of the old hierarchy of priorities: economic development first, the people and places affected by it expected to accommodate the consequences.

Who gets to define progress? Who decides which losses are acceptable? Whose knowledge matters?

And why must the protections we developed through generations of bitter experience be weakened to accommodate the commercial schedules of extraordinarily wealthy enterprises?

If the data-center industry is developing faster than our infrastructure and regulatory systems can responsibly accommodate, perhaps the industry should slow down.

Commercial urgency is not a national emergency merely because someone stands to lose money.

Shelve this bill.

I’m not opposed to improving permitting efficiency. I’m not opposed to transmission modernization. I’m certainly not opposed to protecting ordinary Americans from subsidizing the enormous electrical demands of data centers.

But these are distinct problems, deserving distinct legislation.

Separate the data-center affordability provisions. Address electrical transmission in focused legislation. Hold proper hearings on proposed changes to environmental review, historic preservation, and judicial oversight. Consult Tribal Nations meaningfully, before the decisions have effectively been made.

Let Congress debate each issue on its merits, particularly with voters having now elected new Democratic majorities in both chambers.

If a particular provision cannot command support without being attached to something more popular, perhaps that tells us something important about the provision.

Compromise is necessary in government. But compromise should not become an excuse for dismantling protections that took generations to establish.

Senator Heinrich, I have supported you because I believed you understood these things. But BAAJA leaves me wondering whether the desire to get something accomplished has overtaken the responsibility to consider everything that might be lost in accomplishing it.

New Mexico has spent generations living with the consequences of industrial promises.

We’ve buried the mine waste. We’ve cleaned the rivers. We’ve watched the night skies brighten. We’ve lost archaeological evidence that can never be recovered. We’ve seen communities struggle for decades to obtain remedies for damage they never agreed to accept.

These aren’t theoretical concerns. They’re our history.

And they’re precisely why environmental protections exist.

Please don’t ask us to endure these consequences all over again.